Should transgender people receive government handouts? San Francisco launched a guaranteed income program for low-income transgender residents with payments up to $1,200 each month for up to 18 months. Aldo hits the campus of UC Berkeley to ask students what they think about this program.
#transgender #berkeley #ubi #trans
???? PragerU is experiencing severe censorship on Big Tech platforms, go to PragerU.com to watch our videos free of censorship!
Sign up to never miss a new video! https://www.prageru.com/series/man-on-the-street
Yeah it's called trans so that I can move from one side to another. I'm a male - will identify myself as a female, get the $1200 and then identify back to male again and can I get $1200 again?
@PottersVideos2 Says:
I agree. Everyone should have their needs provided for and not be forced to rely on the generosity of strangers.
@RacerX1971 Says:
No
@mr.gigagod9736 Says:
So they only give money to trans but not the bi, this is offensive.
@1911Earthling Says:
This is funny.
@XrpAndy Says:
These kids are our future leaders. Just let that sink in
@whatrtheodds Says:
Its to help with the transition process. Because they know it will take time for the person to get surgery and socially adjust. I don't like it though, as a person who went through years of domestic violence, which impacted my ability to think as i got stuck in survival mode, because he repeatedly threatened to kill me and physically beat me. I would have benefited greatly from a transition period out of that. Instead i ended up living in my car. i hope they have just as much care for people who are the victims of violent partners like i was.
@mmchayek Says:
The guy is located in the wrong venue. Californians are actually the modern day definition of socialist.
@montanausa329 Says:
Rewarding for failure. The guy from Spain is the only smart one
@pretikewl76 Says:
The moment you favor one group over others, you've destroyed any "equality" you were trying to achieve.
@ItsPrivateCC Says:
If they are at the university, this is a clear example for me that my kids don't need higher education
@captainwiggy4235 Says:
A former 9th-grade student of mine who is now a grown woman, identified as a boy. She took puberty blockers and testosterone. By the time she was in 11th-grade, one would not even have the slightest idea she is female. The staff at our school virtue signaled all along, referring to her as "He" (me included). She graduated and had a mammectomy. She is now 24-years old.
Six months ago she contacted me and informed that she is suicidal. She informed me that she came to the realization that she is not a man. She came to the realization that she is now a mutilated woman, and blames society (teachers and peers included) for her predicament. Due to her taking puberty blockers and testosterone, she is now infertile. She cannot give birth. She doesn't ovulate anymore.
The trans-movement destroyed her womanhood.
She is now suicidal. She realizes that the whole trans-movement is grooming youth. She is really angry at family and former staff for encouraging her attempted (always futile) transition. She asked me recently: "Why did you not tell me the truth? Why did you not try to stop me?" I replied: "If I tried to tell you how I really felt; that people are born xx and will die xx. People are born xy and die xy, I would have been fired". Nothing can change this.
To those who say I am conflating sex and gender, I argue that the trans-community is in fact doing just that, claiming men can get pregnant and have periods; claiming that biological male athletes can compete against women "AS WOMEN!"
I am for personal freedom. I am also for the inalterable fact of science. Anybody who dares to tell the truth is labeled a transphobe.
@readmarx420 Says:
Everyone should be getting money from the government anyway. Taxes are our money anyway
@54000biker Says:
Give someone a fish and you feed them for a day. Teach them to fish and feed them for life.
@Kelly-mi1yz Says:
Of course not
@mawhulk Says:
wait, are these american people in college ?
@tigerw3 Says:
Now i get why california is broke
@user-ox9mk7cr2h Says:
I do not support it, but it should be mentioned that the program is not for all trans people. It’s only for 55 people who have a monthly income of no more than $600. So a small number of very poor people. I think that the government instead should help poor people in general, by helping them getting a job so that they can support themselves, and by making housing affordable to people.
@TinySquirrelCinema Says:
Absolutely garbage answers! WE ARE BEING DIVIDED
@GekkoGeemu Says:
We should all move to Spain and make that guy our King.
@therealmarkzuckerberg Says:
PragerU should listen to Auntie Diaries by Kendrick Lamar
“"Demetrius is Mary-Ann now"
Church, his auntie is a man now, it hurt
Him the most 'cause his belief was close to his words
Forcing me to stand now
I said, "Mr. Preacher man, should we love thy neighbor?"
"The laws of the land or the heart, what's greater?"
"I recognize the study she was taught since birth"
"But that don't justify the feelings that my cousin preserved"
The building was thinking out loud, bad angel
That's when you looked at me and smiled, said, "Thank you"
The day I chose humanity over religion
The family got closer, it was all forgiven”
@johnharden3217 Says:
One question if they are in poverty how did they get the surgery and what did the surgery cost sounds like a lack of priorities what's more important survival or sex change makes no sense
@baronvonchud403 Says:
not like any of them are paying for it.
@streetphone4619 Says:
Is this for real? If so, I don't know, call me alarmist but I predict a lot of straight dudes will suddenly start feeling like a woman - whatever that is.
@TheRealTrueCrimeAnalyst Says:
If you’re interested in learning more about this program, check out the information on San Francisco’s website. As you likely guessed, there is more to it than simply paying transgender people not to work.
@tinda111 Says:
would you rather give money to homeless people or people w mental disorder, US citizen: give money to people w mental disorder
@SL2797 Says:
I would LOVE for commie-fornia to become a fully communist state, and watch the unfolding apocalypse from a safe distance.
@glennmiller9853 Says:
First of all, Prager u is a ridiculously uninformative source that smears facts. Not about this video, just about most videos/issues. And Republicans are a huge reason as to why society can not advance scientifically or socially. But the far left is just making it so hard to defend their actions (not Democrats, I mean the far left, Including California as a whole.) San Francisco is really doing this? It's just discrimination and profiling not to mention it's a strain on taxpayers benefiting people who can work.
I work trading financial derivatives, and this will do nothing good for the economy Ithe long run. As if I really needed to say that.
@christophercirocco8611 Says:
Not sure why we bother asking these questions to college kids? What is the value of that?
@Ariel_Simms Says:
#bringbackwillwitt
@buckfiden946 Says:
I like how one girl asked where is the money coming from. Well, when you work a job you get a pay check, but the government takes what we call taxes from your paycheck. This tax money that you worked to earn is what the government is taking from you and giving to a more privileged person who could more easily find a job than you…they just don’t want to.
@theherpingchannel8180 Says:
@jammidodger
@ivgondef4408 Says:
I will pretend to be trans for my free money.
@TheNitsua59 Says:
I identify as 10 trans people living on the streets of San Francisco. Give me my $12,000 or $144,000 per year. Who knows I might start identifying as 100 trans people.
@scottcorwin3483 Says:
He'll no!
@grainsalt9662 Says:
That is crazy. it steals 175 days I could spend with my family instead they are enslaving me to work for someone else for 175 days a year! so fascist totalitarian , so demoncrapy
@yaboiavery5986 Says:
I swear these ppl don't think about the words coming out of their mouths 👁👄👁
@jesuscazarez5737 Says:
Lmao what a joke along with these idiots agreeing to the program 😂an example of a failed society
@scottschenk5456 Says:
Another Group of Kids who have No Idea what they are talking about aka SO CAL University Snowflakes. Hope their parents are proud!
@onenesswomb Says:
You, cis caucasian males, are a piece of work. Yall are so privileged and disconnected from the reality of others. Not looking up the data and experiences of trans women and men > PragerU knew that asking these questions would be a setup for biggot folks who already have hate and confusion in their hearts for trans people to be negative. I'm clapping for the indigenous students on campus who have a consciousness and see the struggle even tho they are not living the trans experience. This is what you called allyship.
@dagreen8676 Says:
What happens if the minority your in has posters for free income would you take the money or would you say no I don’t take free handouts if you say you take the money that shit ain’t fair man you say don’t give handouts when it came to other minorities but you took a handout when it’s yours
@redblaze8700 Says:
Great, another video by conservatives whose main purpose is to promote hatred and bigotry.
@rawchickensandwich Says:
Give them money so they can sit around and spread monkey pox instead of work.
@jiyakuches220 Says:
I honestly don't care if whatever heterosexual, homosexual, transgender, demi etc.
Should we give government handouts? Private agencies from companies can help, not governments.
Host courses to improve/prepare for employees/job seekers; a single payment doesn't help; everything has a cost.
@edsel762 Says:
How about helping our veterans? Tunnel2Tower is a great starting place.
@diversezebra6754 Says:
That guy from Spain and the black woman were the only ones talking any kind of sense. .-. How wild is that.
@alaia-awakened Says:
Isn’t this is a financial incentive to become trans?
@JChannel_ Says:
I feel like we should advocate that San Francisco pays for trans people cradle to grave. 🥁 San Francisco should pay for transition surgery and treatments and should definitely pay trans child care and even give free scholarships to trans people. Why not! Don’t be so transphobic San Francisco be great allies.
@bweaver760 Says:
These Berkeley people do not seem very intelligent! Shills!
@vinay33310 Says:
tax payers are funding the government. They have every right to say how that money has to be spent. So just allow Tax payers to vote for congress and Whitehouse. Welfare dwellers are voting to get others money which is stealing. so revoke their vote. Do I sound illogical?
LATEST COMMENTS